Why I’m not a fan of book reviews


As someone who reads a fair number of books, and who loves adding new (or new-to-me) books to my collection, I have a confession: I don’t put much stock in book reviews.


I typically choose books based on the recommendations of friends or how intriguing I find the description or blurb on the cover (although I’ve sometimes found even those to be misleading).


But then all bets are off once I start reading. Some books that I never expected to enjoy are now on my list of favorites. Some that I thought I would like are now in the give-away pile.


Do you have a Goodreads account? I have one, but only for keeping a handy list of books I want to remember to look for … for me, it’s simply a portable want-to-read list.


Sometimes, though, I find myself scrolling through the reader reviews of a book I’m contemplating adding to the list, or one that I’m reading or have just finished. And I’m often amazed by the shockingly wide variety of opinions expressed as absolutes.


Don’t get me wrong: I fully expect differing opinions on any book. But I don’t understand the tendency to proclaim a particular book either terrible or triumphant, all based on mere opinion and reader taste. There will always be books you love that others don’t; and popular books or “must-reads” that you don’t like.


This is why I only offer book suggestions, not reviews.


All of the “books we love” — here on the website, in the Read. Purr. newsletter, and on social media — are just that: books we truly adored. And I will gladly share why I loved the book or — in conversation, at any rate — why I didn’t care for a particular title. But I won’t insist that “you must read this.”


Because, ultimately, the choice is yours.


Choose the books that speak to you, and read what you enjoy; not what everyone else — or even that one person whose opinion you respect — enjoys or says you “should” read.


We all have our own unique tastes. And reading is an intensely personal relationship between you and the book in your hands.


“… Some enjoyed them and others did not but that is the nature of a story. Not all stories speak to all listeners, but all listeners can find a story that does, somewhere, sometime.”  — Erin Morgenstern, The Starless Sea

Want more? Join us!

Subscribe to our occasional email letters and, as a thank-you gift, we’ll send you our exclusive guide to achieving Read. Purr. bliss: reliable relaxation & contentment in 5 easy steps.

Hello & Welcome

I’m Jennifer: reader of fiction, cat whisperer, nerdy introvert. Possessor of a vivid imagination, a massive streak of curiosity, and a love of puzzles. Firm believer in — and ready to help you discover — the health-and-happiness benefits of reading and quiet time, whether indoors or out; “everyday” mindfulness; gardening; and walks in nature. Artist, writer, and founder of the Read. Purr. Collective.